Withdrawal of Manuscript

HALAL REVIEWS recognises that authors may occasionally need to withdraw a manuscript from consideration. However, manuscript withdrawal at different stages of the editorial and publication process may have implications for editorial resources, peer reviewers, and the integrity of the scholarly record. Accordingly, authors are expected to observe the following policy.

1. Withdrawal Before Peer Review

Authors who wish to withdraw a manuscript before the commencement of external peer review must submit a written request to the Editorial Office, providing a brief explanation for the withdrawal. No withdrawal penalty will ordinarily apply at this stage, as the manuscript has not yet proceeded through the external peer-review process.

2. Withdrawal During Peer Review

Withdrawal of a manuscript while the peer-review process is in progress is strongly discouraged, as editorial and reviewer resources may already have been committed. Authors requesting withdrawal at this stage must submit a formal written request to the Editorial Office, stating the reasons for withdrawal.

The withdrawal request will be reviewed by the Editorial Office, which may seek clarification where necessary. Authors must obtain written confirmation of the withdrawal before submitting the same manuscript to another journal. Any applicable administrative charges, if introduced, shall be governed by the journal's published fee policy.

3. Withdrawal After Acceptance but Before Publication

Withdrawal of an accepted manuscript is strongly discouraged because the journal may already have invested resources in copyediting, typesetting, DOI registration, and other publication-related processes.

Authors seeking withdrawal at this stage must submit a formal written request with a clear and compelling justification. The request will be considered by the Editorial Office, taking into account the stage of publication, the circumstances of the request, and any applicable publication agreements or fee policies. Authors must receive written confirmation from the Editorial Office before treating the manuscript as withdrawn.

4. Withdrawal After Publication

Once an article has been formally published, it becomes part of the permanent scholarly record and cannot ordinarily be withdrawn through the standard manuscript withdrawal process.

If a significant error, ethical concern, instance of plagiarism, or other serious issue is identified after publication, HALAL REVIEWS will assess the matter in accordance with its publication ethics policies and applicable scholarly publishing standards. Where appropriate, the journal may issue a correction, erratum, expression of concern, or retraction. Any such action will be documented transparently, with the relevant notice linked to the published article, in accordance with applicable guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

5. Withdrawal Without Formal Notification

Authors must not assume that a manuscript has been withdrawn merely by ceasing communication with the Editorial Office. Similarly, submitting the same or substantially similar manuscript to another journal while it remains under consideration by HALAL REVIEWS may constitute a breach of publication ethics.

Where such circumstances arise, the Editorial Office will assess the matter in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies and provide the authors with an opportunity to clarify the situation, where appropriate. Any subsequent action will be proportionate to the circumstances and consistent with applicable publication ethics standards.

6. Procedure for Requesting Withdrawal

All manuscript withdrawal requests must be submitted in writing to the Editorial Office by the corresponding author, acting on behalf of all co-authors. The request must include the following information:

  1. The full title of the manuscript.

  2. The manuscript submission ID, where available.

  3. The names of all authors.

  4. A clear explanation for the withdrawal request.

  5. Confirmation that all co-authors have agreed to the withdrawal.

The Editorial Office will acknowledge receipt of the request and communicate its decision in writing. Until written confirmation has been issued, authors should not assume that the withdrawal has been formally completed.

HALAL REVIEWS is committed to ensuring that manuscript withdrawal is handled fairly, transparently, and consistently, while safeguarding editorial integrity, respecting the contributions of reviewers, and maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.