Plagiarism Policy

Plagiarism Policy

1. Statement of Commitment

HALAL REVIEWS (E-ISSN: 2805-4490) is committed to upholding academic integrity, originality, transparency, and ethical scholarly publishing. Plagiarism and other forms of unattributed use of intellectual work undermine the credibility of academic research and are considered serious breaches of publication ethics.

The journal expects all authors to ensure that their manuscripts represent original scholarly contributions and that all sources, ideas, quotations, data, and materials derived from other works are appropriately acknowledged.

This policy applies to all manuscripts submitted to HALAL REVIEWS and to articles published in the journal.

2. Definition of Plagiarism

Plagiarism refers to the use of another person's words, ideas, data, findings, images, or other intellectual contributions without appropriate acknowledgement, attribution, or permission where required.

Plagiarism may take several forms, including but not limited to:

  • Direct plagiarism: Reproducing text or other material verbatim without appropriate quotation marks, attribution, or citation.

  • Paraphrasing plagiarism: Rewriting another person's ideas or arguments without acknowledging the original source.

  • Mosaic plagiarism: Combining phrases, sentences, or ideas from multiple sources without adequate attribution.

  • Data and image plagiarism: Using data, figures, tables, images, or other research materials without appropriate acknowledgement or authorisation where required.

  • Self-plagiarism: Reusing substantial portions of one's own previously published work without appropriate citation, disclosure, or justification.

  • Inappropriate source attribution: Citing sources inaccurately or presenting another person's contribution as one's own.

  • Unacknowledged use of AI-generated material: Presenting AI-generated content in a manner that misrepresents authorship or breaches the journal's AI Use Policy.

Legitimate quotation, appropriately attributed paraphrasing, and permitted reuse of material are not automatically considered plagiarism. Each case will be assessed in context, taking into account the nature and extent of the overlap, attribution practices, and applicable copyright and publication ethics requirements.

3. Plagiarism Detection and Screening Procedure

HALAL REVIEWS screens submitted manuscripts for potential plagiarism and inappropriate textual or material overlap as part of its editorial assessment.

The screening process may include the following procedures:

  1. Initial editorial examination: The Editorial Office examines the manuscript for citation accuracy, quotation practices, source attribution, and other indicators of potential plagiarism.

  2. Similarity checking: Manuscripts may be screened using plagiarism detection software, such as Turnitin or an equivalent tool, where available.

  3. Assessment of similarity reports: The editorial team evaluates the similarity report to identify the nature, source, and significance of overlapping material.

  4. Further clarification: Where necessary, authors may be asked to explain identified similarities, provide supporting documentation, or revise the manuscript.

  5. Editorial decision: The Editor-in-Chief or authorised editorial representative determines the appropriate action based on the available evidence and the journal's publication ethics policies.

A similarity score is an indicator of textual overlap and does not, by itself, establish whether plagiarism has occurred. Properly cited quotations, reference lists, standard terminology, commonly used phrases, and methodological descriptions may contribute to a similarity score without necessarily constituting plagiarism.

HALAL REVIEWS may use a similarity score of 20% as an indicative screening threshold, subject to editorial assessment and the journal's operational procedures. Manuscripts exceeding this threshold may undergo further scrutiny and may be returned for revision or rejected where the overlap is substantial or indicates a serious breach of publication ethics. A score below the threshold does not guarantee that a manuscript is free from plagiarism.

4. Author Responsibilities and Prevention

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their submissions comply with accepted standards of academic integrity. To prevent plagiarism, authors must:

  • Cite and reference all sources used in developing their research, arguments, analysis, and conclusions.

  • Use quotation marks or appropriate block quotation formatting for verbatim extracts, accompanied by accurate citations.

  • Paraphrase source material genuinely and acknowledge the original author or source.

  • Clearly distinguish their original contributions from previously published research and established scholarly arguments.

  • Obtain permission for copyrighted material where required by the applicable licence or law.

  • Ensure that references are accurate, complete, and consistent with the journal's Author Guidelines.

  • Disclose relevant previous publications and substantial overlap with earlier work.

  • Ensure that all co-authors understand and accept responsibility for the originality and integrity of the submitted manuscript.

Authors must not fabricate citations, misrepresent the work of other researchers, or manipulate similarity reports to conceal unattributed material.

5. Self-Plagiarism and Redundant Publication

Authors must not republish substantial portions of their own previously published work as new and original research without appropriate citation, disclosure, and justification.

The journal recognises that certain overlap may be legitimate in circumstances such as the reuse of standard methodological descriptions or the development of a previously presented conference paper into a substantially expanded journal article. Such cases must be disclosed where relevant and must comply with the journal's submission requirements and applicable copyright arrangements.

Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to HALAL REVIEWS and another journal. Manuscripts that have been published elsewhere, or that substantially overlap with existing publications, must be disclosed during submission.

Duplicate or redundant publication will be assessed according to the extent of the overlap, the level of disclosure, the originality of the contribution, and the applicable publication ethics standards.

6. Consequences of Plagiarism

Where plagiarism or other serious forms of unattributed use are identified, HALAL REVIEWS will assess the evidence and determine an appropriate response.

Depending on the seriousness, extent, and circumstances of the case, possible actions include:

  1. Request for clarification or revision: Authors may be asked to explain the overlap or correct inadequate attribution where the issue is limited and can appropriately be resolved.

  2. Rejection of the manuscript: A manuscript may be rejected where substantial plagiarism, deliberate misrepresentation, or other serious ethical violations are established.

  3. Post-publication correction or retraction: If plagiarism is identified after publication, the journal may issue a correction, expression of concern, or retraction in accordance with its relevant policies.

  4. Notification of relevant institutions: Serious cases may be referred to the author's institution, research funder, or another appropriate authority where justified.

  5. Restrictions on future submissions: In cases of serious or repeated misconduct, the journal may impose proportionate restrictions on future submissions, consistent with its policies and applicable ethical standards.

Any action will be based on the evidence available and the seriousness of the breach. Authors will ordinarily be given an opportunity to respond before a final adverse decision is made.

The journal will protect the confidentiality of investigations to the extent reasonably possible. Public disclosure of the identities of individuals involved will not be automatic and will be considered only where justified by the circumstances, applicable law, and relevant publication ethics principles.

7. Relationship with Other Publication Ethics Policies

This policy should be read together with the HALAL REVIEWS Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement, Research Misconduct Policy, AI Use Policy, and Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern Policy.

Suspected plagiarism will be handled consistently with these policies and relevant guidance from recognised scholarly publishing ethics organisations, including the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), where applicable.

8. Commitment to Academic Integrity

HALAL REVIEWS is committed to fostering a culture of originality, responsible scholarship, accurate attribution, and respect for intellectual property. Authors, reviewers, and editors share responsibility for maintaining the integrity and credibility of the scholarly record.

By submitting a manuscript to HALAL REVIEWS, authors acknowledge their responsibility to comply with this policy and the journal's broader publication ethics requirements.