Generative AI Policy

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Use Policy

1. Scope

This policy governs the use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools and AI-assisted technologies in the preparation, submission, peer review, and editorial handling of manuscripts submitted to or published in HALAL REVIEWS (E-ISSN: 2805-4490).

Such technologies include, but are not limited to, large language models and AI-powered applications such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, and comparable tools used for writing, translation, research assistance, data analysis, image generation, or other scholarly activities.

HALAL REVIEWS recognises that AI technologies may support certain research and publishing tasks. However, their use must be transparent, responsible, and consistent with research integrity, confidentiality, copyright, and publication ethics requirements.

2. Core Principle: AI Cannot Be an Author

Generative AI tools and AI-assisted technologies cannot be listed as authors of manuscripts submitted to HALAL REVIEWS.

Authorship requires intellectual contribution, accountability, and the ability to take responsibility for the integrity of the research and the published work. AI systems cannot independently fulfil these responsibilities.

Human authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and ethical compliance of their manuscripts, including any content produced or modified with AI assistance.

Authors must ensure that AI-assisted content does not misrepresent the research, reproduce unattributed material, introduce fabricated references, or compromise the reliability of scholarly claims.

3. Permitted Uses of AI

Authors may use AI tools to support appropriate tasks in manuscript preparation, provided that their use does not replace the authors' intellectual contribution or compromise research integrity.

Permitted uses may include:

  • Language editing: Checking grammar, spelling, punctuation, readability, and sentence structure.

  • Translation assistance: Supporting translation between languages, subject to human verification of accuracy, meaning, and appropriate scholarly terminology.

  • Formatting and organisation: Assisting with document formatting, reference organisation, and compliance with submission requirements.

  • Literature search assistance: Supporting the identification of potentially relevant literature, provided that authors independently verify the existence, authenticity, relevance, and accuracy of all sources.

  • Technical assistance: Supporting appropriate coding, data processing, or other technical tasks, provided that the methods and outputs are independently checked and accurately reported.

The use of AI must not replace the authors' responsibility for critical analysis, interpretation, methodological decisions, or scholarly conclusions.

Authors are responsible for verifying all AI-assisted outputs before incorporating them into a manuscript.

4. Restricted and Prohibited Uses of AI

AI must not be used in ways that undermine the originality, accuracy, transparency, or ethical integrity of scholarly research.

The following practices are prohibited:

  • Fabrication or falsification: Generating or manipulating research data, results, images, references, quotations, or other evidence in a misleading manner.

  • False attribution: Presenting AI-generated content as verified research findings or attributing statements, ideas, or conclusions to sources that do not support them.

  • Unverified references: Including fabricated, inaccurate, or non-existent citations generated by AI.

  • Misrepresentation of scholarly contribution: Using AI-generated material in a manner that misrepresents the authors' intellectual contribution or conceals the extent of AI involvement where disclosure is required.

  • Academic misconduct: Using AI to facilitate plagiarism, disguise unattributed copying, manipulate similarity-checking systems, or deceive editors and reviewers.

  • Inappropriate research substitution: Relying on AI-generated literature reviews, theoretical arguments, methodological decisions, interpretations, or conclusions without sufficient human scholarly evaluation and independent verification.

  • Confidentiality violations: Uploading confidential manuscripts, unpublished research, personal data, or other restricted information to AI tools where such disclosure is unauthorised or confidentiality cannot be adequately protected.

AI-assisted research and writing must comply with applicable ethical standards, copyright requirements, data protection obligations, and the journal's other publication policies.

5. Disclosure Requirements

Authors must disclose the use of generative AI tools where those tools have made a substantive contribution to manuscript preparation, content generation, analysis, translation, or other activities for which disclosure is required by the journal.

The disclosure should identify:

  1. The name of the AI tool and, where available, the model or version used.

  2. The purpose and nature of its use.

  3. The relevant part of the research or manuscript preparation process in which the tool was used.

  4. Confirmation that the authors have reviewed and verified the relevant outputs and accept full responsibility for the submitted work.

Routine assistance such as basic spelling correction or standard grammar checking may be exempt from disclosure where the journal's applicable instructions expressly permit this exemption.

An appropriate disclosure statement may be written as follows:

“The authors used [name of AI tool and model/version, where available] for [specific purpose, such as language editing or translation assistance] during the preparation of this manuscript. All AI-assisted outputs were reviewed and verified by the authors, who take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and final content of the manuscript.”

Authors should place the disclosure in the Methods section, Acknowledgements section, or another location specified by the journal, depending on the nature of the AI use.

Where no generative AI tools have been used in a manner requiring disclosure, no declaration of AI use is necessary unless otherwise requested by the journal.

6. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors bear full responsibility for all content submitted to HALAL REVIEWS, regardless of whether AI tools were used during its preparation.

Authors must:

  • Verify the accuracy and reliability of AI-generated or AI-assisted content.

  • Check that all references, quotations, legal provisions, scientific claims, and other cited materials are authentic and accurately represented.

  • Ensure that the manuscript reflects their own scholarly judgement and intellectual contribution.

  • Disclose relevant AI use in accordance with this policy.

  • Ensure that AI use does not breach copyright, confidentiality, privacy, or research ethics requirements.

  • Correct any errors or misleading content identified before or after publication.

The use of AI does not exempt authors from accountability for errors, research misconduct, or breaches of publication ethics.

7. Responsibilities of Reviewers and Editors

Reviewers and editors must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts and associated editorial correspondence throughout the publication process.

They must not upload unpublished manuscripts, confidential peer-review reports, identifiable author information, or other restricted editorial materials to public or third-party AI tools where confidentiality cannot be assured or where such use is unauthorised.

Any AI-assisted tool used in editorial or peer-review work must be consistent with the journal's confidentiality requirements and applicable editorial procedures. AI tools may support administrative or analytical tasks where permitted, but they must not replace the independent scholarly judgement of reviewers or editorial decision-makers.

Reviewers and editors remain responsible for the accuracy, fairness, confidentiality, and integrity of their work.

8. Screening, Investigation, and Consequences

HALAL REVIEWS may assess suspected violations of this policy through editorial screening, examination of the manuscript, verification of cited sources, requests for clarification, and other appropriate investigative procedures.

AI-detection software or similar automated tools may be used as supplementary indicators where available. However, such tools are not definitive proof of misconduct and should not be the sole basis for an adverse editorial decision.

Where concerns arise, the journal may request an explanation or additional information from the authors and assess the matter in accordance with its Research Misconduct Policy and other relevant publication ethics policies.

Depending on the seriousness and circumstances of a confirmed violation, the journal may:

  • Request clarification or correction of the manuscript.

  • Require revisions or additional verification.

  • Reject a manuscript before publication.

  • Publish a correction or expression of concern for a published article.

  • Retract a published article where the circumstances warrant retraction.

  • Refer serious concerns to the relevant institution or other appropriate authority, where justified.

Any action will be proportionate to the nature of the violation and based on the available evidence.

9. Policy Review

HALAL REVIEWS will review this policy periodically to reflect developments in AI technologies, research integrity standards, copyright requirements, and scholarly publishing practices.

The journal encourages the responsible use of AI where appropriate, while maintaining the principle that scholarly accountability, critical judgement, and responsibility for published research remain with human authors, reviewers, and editors.