Publication Ethics and Misconduct

Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

1. Statement of Principles

HALAL REVIEWS (E-ISSN: 2805-4490) is committed to maintaining high standards of research integrity, academic honesty, transparency, and publication ethics. The journal seeks to ensure that all manuscripts are assessed and published in accordance with recognised principles of responsible scholarly publishing.

This policy draws on established publication ethics principles and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), together with applicable research integrity standards and institutional requirements. All parties involved in the publication process, including authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher, are expected to uphold these principles.

HALAL REVIEWS is committed to ensuring that editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, originality, relevance, methodological rigour, and compliance with ethical requirements, without inappropriate influence from commercial, personal, or institutional interests.

2. Duties and Responsibilities of Authors

2.1 Originality and Plagiarism

Authors must ensure that submitted manuscripts represent original scholarly work and that all sources, ideas, data, and materials derived from other works are appropriately acknowledged through citation, quotation, or other suitable attribution.

Plagiarism includes the unattributed use of another person's words, ideas, data, or research findings. It may also include inappropriate reuse of an author's previously published material without adequate acknowledgement or disclosure.

Manuscripts must not contain fabricated or falsified information or other forms of research misrepresentation. Where plagiarism or other serious ethical concerns are identified, the journal may reject the manuscript, request clarification, or take further action in accordance with its publication ethics policies.

2.2 Authorship and Contributions

Authorship must accurately reflect the substantial scholarly contributions made by individuals to the research and manuscript. All listed authors must have contributed meaningfully to the work, participated in drafting or critically revising the manuscript, approved the final version, and agreed to its submission and publication.

The corresponding author is responsible for coordinating communication with the Editorial Office and confirming that all eligible contributors are appropriately acknowledged and that all co-authors have approved the submitted manuscript.

Guest authorship, ghost authorship, coerced authorship, and other inappropriate authorship practices are not permitted. Contributions that do not meet the journal's authorship requirements should be acknowledged appropriately, with the consent of the individuals concerned.

Any proposed change to authorship after submission must be explained to the Editorial Office and supported by the agreement of all relevant authors. The journal reserves the right to assess such requests before making a decision.

2.3 Multiple Submission and Redundant Publication

Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to HALAL REVIEWS and another journal. Manuscripts under consideration must not be submitted elsewhere until a formal withdrawal has been confirmed or an editorial decision has otherwise concluded the submission process.

Authors must disclose any previous publication, submission, or dissemination of substantially overlapping material. Where a manuscript builds on previously published research, the relationship between the works must be clearly explained and the relevant sources cited.

Redundant publication, inappropriate duplicate publication, and undisclosed substantial overlap may constitute breaches of publication ethics.

2.4 Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest

Authors must disclose any financial, professional, institutional, personal, or other interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing their research, analysis, or conclusions.

All sources of financial support, including grants, institutional funding, sponsorship, and other relevant assistance, must be acknowledged appropriately.

A conflict-of-interest declaration and funding statement must be provided where applicable, including an explicit statement when no relevant competing interests or external funding exist, in accordance with the journal's submission requirements.

2.5 Data Accuracy, Integrity, and Availability

Authors are responsible for ensuring that research data, analyses, images, tables, and reported findings are accurate and presented honestly.

Fabrication, falsification, selective manipulation, and misleading presentation of research evidence are unacceptable. Authors must provide sufficient methodological information to support scholarly evaluation and, where appropriate, facilitate verification or replication.

Authors should retain relevant research records and supporting data for a reasonable period, subject to applicable legal, ethical, privacy, and institutional requirements. Where justified, the Editorial Office may request access to supporting data or documentation to clarify concerns regarding a manuscript or published article.

Any sharing of research data must respect confidentiality, informed consent, intellectual property rights, and applicable data protection requirements.

2.6 Errors in Published Work

Authors who discover a significant error or inaccuracy in their published work must promptly notify the Editor-in-Chief or Editorial Office and cooperate in assessing the matter.

Depending on the nature and seriousness of the error, the journal may publish a correction, corrigendum, expression of concern, retraction, or another appropriate notice in accordance with its relevant policies.

2.7 Research Ethics and Ethical Approval

Research involving human participants, identifiable personal information, sensitive data, or human biological materials must comply with applicable ethical standards, institutional requirements, and relevant national regulations.

Where required, authors must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee or institutional review board before conducting the research. The manuscript must identify the approving body and provide the relevant approval reference, where applicable.

Authors must also report informed consent procedures where relevant and demonstrate appropriate safeguards for participants' rights, safety, privacy, and confidentiality.

Research involving animals must comply with applicable animal welfare legislation, ethical standards, and institutional approval requirements in the jurisdiction where the research was conducted.

For research involving halal products, food safety, pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, or other regulated activities, authors must comply with relevant regulatory and ethical requirements. Claims relating to halal status, certification, or compliance should be supported by appropriate evidence and accurately represented.

2.8 Use of Artificial Intelligence

Authors must comply with the journal's applicable requirements concerning the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted tools in research and manuscript preparation.

AI tools must not be listed as authors. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and ethical compliance of their submissions, including the verification of AI-generated text, references, data, images, and other content.

Where disclosure is required by the journal, authors must clearly identify the use of AI-assisted tools and describe their role in the research or preparation of the manuscript. AI tools must not be used to fabricate research evidence, generate false references, conceal plagiarism, or misrepresent the conduct or findings of research.

3. Duties and Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the academic quality and integrity of HALAL REVIEWS. All reviewers are expected to observe the following responsibilities:

  • Confidentiality: Treat manuscripts and related correspondence as confidential and do not disclose or distribute unpublished content without appropriate authorisation.

  • Objectivity: Conduct reviews fairly, professionally, and without personal bias. Comments must focus on the scholarly quality of the manuscript rather than the authors personally.

  • Conflicts of interest: Disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest before accepting a review invitation and decline the assignment where impartiality may be compromised.

  • Integrity of unpublished material: Do not use unpublished information, ideas, data, or findings obtained through peer review for personal, academic, or commercial advantage.

  • Identification of ethical concerns: Inform the Editor-in-Chief or Editorial Office of suspected plagiarism, redundant publication, data irregularities, inappropriate authorship, or other possible ethical violations.

  • Timeliness: Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe or notify the Editorial Office promptly if additional time is required.

  • AI-assisted tools: Follow the journal's applicable rules on AI-assisted review and do not disclose confidential manuscript content to AI tools or external services where confidentiality cannot be assured.

Reviewers should provide clear, evidence-based recommendations and constructive feedback that assists the editorial decision-making process and, where appropriate, helps authors improve their manuscripts.

4. Duties and Responsibilities of the Editor-in-Chief and Editorial Board

4.1 Editorial Decisions

The Editor-in-Chief or an authorised editorial representative is responsible for ensuring that manuscripts are evaluated according to their scholarly merit, originality, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, methodological quality, and compliance with publication ethics.

Editorial decisions must not be influenced by an author's race, ethnicity, gender, nationality, religious beliefs, institutional affiliation, personal relationships, or other irrelevant characteristics.

The final decision on acceptance, revision, or rejection rests with the authorised editorial decision-maker, taking into account the review reports and applicable journal policies.

4.2 Confidentiality

Editors must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts under consideration and restrict access to those who require the information for legitimate editorial purposes.

Manuscript content, reviewer identities, author information, and editorial correspondence must not be disclosed inappropriately to third parties.

4.3 Conflicts of Interest

Editors must disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest and withdraw from handling a manuscript where their impartiality may reasonably be questioned.

Where necessary, the manuscript will be assigned to an independent editor or another appropriately authorised decision-maker.

4.4 Fair Peer Review

Editors must ensure that manuscripts are handled through the journal's established peer-review procedures. Reviewers should be selected based on relevant expertise, impartiality, and suitability for the subject matter.

Editors must consider reviewer reports carefully and address significant disagreements, ethical concerns, or procedural irregularities before making an editorial decision.

4.5 Handling Ethical Complaints

Editors must take appropriate action when concerns are raised regarding submitted manuscripts, published articles, reviewer conduct, authorship, or other aspects of the publication process.

Depending on the circumstances, this may include seeking clarification, requesting supporting evidence, consulting independent experts, contacting relevant institutions, or issuing a correction, expression of concern, or retraction.

Editors must also ensure that individuals handling ethical complaints disclose conflicts of interest and that the investigation is conducted fairly and confidentially.

5. Research Misconduct and Investigation

HALAL REVIEWS takes allegations of research misconduct seriously. Such allegations may involve data fabrication or falsification, plagiarism, redundant publication, authorship manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, peer-review manipulation, or other serious breaches of research integrity.

Allegations will be assessed in accordance with the journal's Research Misconduct Policy and relevant publication ethics guidance.

The journal may request explanations and supporting documentation from the relevant authors, consult independent experts, or refer serious cases to the appropriate research institution, funding body, ethics committee, or other competent authority.

Where misconduct or serious publication concerns are established, the journal may reject a manuscript, issue a correction, publish an expression of concern, retract an article, or take other appropriate action consistent with its policies and the available evidence.

All cases will be handled with due regard for confidentiality, fairness, impartiality, and the integrity of the scholarly record.

6. Post-Publication Amendments

HALAL REVIEWS recognises its responsibility to correct the scholarly record when significant errors or ethical concerns arise after publication. The appropriate action will depend on the nature, seriousness, and implications of the issue.

6.1 Erratum

An erratum is a formal notice correcting a significant error introduced during the journal's editorial, copyediting, typesetting, or production process that affects the accuracy or interpretation of the published article.

6.2 Corrigendum

A corrigendum is a formal notice correcting a significant error originating from the author(s) that affects the accuracy, interpretation, or reliability of the published work but does not require retraction.

6.3 Retraction

A retraction is a formal notice indicating that a published article should no longer be relied upon as part of the scholarly record because of serious errors, research misconduct, or other significant ethical concerns.

Grounds may include major errors that invalidate the findings, data fabrication or falsification, plagiarism, serious ethical violations, or other circumstances that undermine the reliability of the publication.

Retracted articles will ordinarily remain accessible on the journal's website, clearly identified as retracted, with a notice explaining the reasons for the action. Relevant publication metadata will be updated, and applicable indexing services will be notified where appropriate and feasible.

6.4 Expression of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when credible questions have arisen about the reliability or ethical integrity of a published article, but the available evidence is insufficient to reach a final conclusion or an investigation remains ongoing.

The notice alerts readers to the concern while further assessment takes place. The journal may issue a subsequent correction, retraction, or other notice when additional information becomes available.

6.5 Addendum

An addendum is a supplementary notice providing additional information relevant to a previously published article that was not included in the original publication.

An addendum may be appropriate where the additional information improves the completeness or understanding of the published work without requiring a correction or retraction. It must be clearly linked to the original article and must not be used to obscure substantive errors or misconduct.

All post-publication notices will be handled in accordance with the journal's Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern Policy.

7. Publisher Responsibilities

The publisher is responsible for supporting the journal's editorial processes, publication infrastructure, and implementation of its published policies.

The publisher must respect editorial independence and must not improperly influence editorial decisions for commercial, financial, personal, or institutional reasons.

The publisher should support appropriate measures to investigate publication ethics concerns, maintain the integrity of the published record, and ensure that relevant corrections or notices are implemented accurately.

Where a concern involves the publisher or an individual with authority over the editorial process, appropriate independent arrangements should be considered to support impartial handling.

8. Transparency and Policy Implementation

HALAL REVIEWS is committed to making its publication ethics policies publicly accessible and applying them consistently across the editorial and publication process.

Authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher are expected to familiarise themselves with the relevant policies and cooperate in maintaining responsible scholarly publishing practices.

The journal may revise this statement periodically to reflect changes in publication ethics guidance, research integrity standards, applicable regulations, and scholarly publishing practices.

Through these principles, HALAL REVIEWS seeks to foster a culture of academic honesty, accountability, fairness, and trust, while protecting the integrity and long-term value of the scholarly record.