Retraction and Correction

Overview

HALAL REVIEWS (E-ISSN: 2805-4490) is committed to maintaining an accurate, reliable, transparent, and trustworthy scholarly record. The journal recognises its responsibility to address significant errors, research misconduct, and other concerns that may affect the integrity or reliability of published articles.

Where necessary, HALAL REVIEWS will take appropriate corrective action in a timely and transparent manner, guided by established publication ethics principles and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). All cases will be assessed individually, taking into consideration the nature and seriousness of the concern, the available evidence, and the responses of the parties involved.

Corrections: Erratum and Corrigendum

Corrections may be issued when errors are identified in a published article and those errors affect its accuracy, interpretation, or integrity. The type of correction will depend on the nature and origin of the error.

Erratum

An erratum may be issued when a significant error is introduced during the journal's editorial, copyediting, typesetting, or production process. Examples include errors in author affiliations, tables, figures, formatting, or other published content that materially affect the accuracy or interpretation of the article.

Corrigendum

A corrigendum may be issued when an author identifies or is found to have made a significant error in the original manuscript that affects the accuracy, interpretation, or reliability of the published work, but does not warrant retraction of the article.

Minor errors that do not materially affect the meaning, interpretation, or scholarly integrity of an article may be addressed through an appropriate update to the published record, where justified and technically feasible.

All formal corrections will be documented through a correction notice that identifies the original article, describes the error, explains the correction, and is linked to the published version of record. The journal will maintain transparency regarding the nature and extent of the changes.

Retractions

A retraction may be issued when a published article is found to be unreliable or when serious ethical breaches undermine the integrity of the research or publication. Retraction decisions will be made in accordance with applicable publication ethics principles and relevant COPE guidance.

Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:

  • Major errors in research design, methodology, data, or analysis that invalidate the findings or conclusions.

  • Data fabrication, falsification, manipulation, or other forms of research misconduct.

  • Plagiarism or substantial unattributed use of another person's work.

  • Redundant or duplicate publication that violates accepted publication ethics.

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest that materially compromise the research or its interpretation.

  • Failure to obtain required research ethics approval or serious violations of research ethics.

  • Other circumstances in which the published article is demonstrably unreliable or its continued presentation without a retraction notice would mislead readers.

A retraction may be initiated following a request from the authors, an institution, a reader, or another relevant party, or through the journal's own editorial assessment. The Editor-in-Chief or authorised editorial representative will evaluate the available evidence before making a decision.

Retracted articles will ordinarily remain accessible on the journal's website to preserve the scholarly record. The article will be clearly identified as RETRACTED, and a separate retraction notice will explain the reasons for the action to the extent that the information can appropriately be disclosed.

The journal will update the relevant publication metadata and notify applicable indexing services and repositories, where appropriate and feasible, so that the retraction status can be reflected in bibliographic records.

Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when the Editor-in-Chief or editorial board identifies credible reasons to question the reliability or ethical integrity of a published article, but the available evidence is insufficient to reach a final decision.

This notice may be appropriate when:

  • An investigation into suspected research misconduct is ongoing.

  • Relevant evidence remains incomplete or inconclusive.

  • An institutional investigation has been delayed or cannot be completed within a reasonable timeframe.

  • Other significant concerns require readers to be informed while further clarification is sought.

An expression of concern will identify the article in question and explain the nature of the concern to the extent possible without prejudicing an ongoing investigation or disclosing confidential information improperly.

Following the conclusion of the investigation, the journal will determine whether further action is necessary, including the publication of a correction, retraction, or an additional notice clarifying the outcome.

Procedures for Handling Publication Concerns

HALAL REVIEWS will handle allegations and concerns regarding published articles through a fair, confidential, and evidence-based process.

The procedure will generally involve the following steps:

  1. Receipt of a concern: The Editor-in-Chief or Editorial Office receives an allegation, complaint, or report concerning the accuracy, reliability, or ethical integrity of a published article.

  2. Preliminary assessment: The editorial team evaluates the nature and seriousness of the concern and determines whether further assessment or investigation is warranted.

  3. Notification and response: The relevant authors are informed of the concern and given a reasonable opportunity to provide an explanation or supporting evidence, where appropriate.

  4. Further investigation: Where necessary, the journal may seek additional information from the authors, reviewers, research institutions, ethics committees, funders, or other relevant parties. Applicable COPE guidance and procedures will be consulted where appropriate.

  5. Editorial decision: The Editor-in-Chief or authorised editorial representative considers the available evidence and determines the appropriate course of action.

  6. Communication of the outcome: The decision and its rationale are communicated to the relevant parties, subject to confidentiality and applicable legal or ethical obligations.

  7. Publication of a notice: Where warranted, the journal publishes an erratum, corrigendum, retraction notice, expression of concern, or other appropriate editorial notice and links it to the original article.

  8. Record updates and notifications: Where appropriate, the journal updates the article's metadata and notifies relevant indexing services, repositories, institutions, or other parties that require the information.

The steps may be adapted to the circumstances of an individual case, particularly where urgent action is necessary to protect readers or preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

Author Responsibilities and Cooperation

Authors are expected to cooperate with the journal in resolving concerns relating to their published work. They should provide accurate information, respond to editorial enquiries within a reasonable timeframe, and disclose any relevant evidence that may assist the assessment.

Authors may request a correction or raise concerns about a published article by submitting a written explanation and supporting documentation to the Editorial Office. Any request will be evaluated independently and in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

Failure to respond to an enquiry will not, by itself, establish that misconduct has occurred. However, the journal may proceed with its assessment using the evidence available and may contact the relevant institution or authority where appropriate.

7. Editorial Independence and Transparency

Decisions concerning corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern will be based on the evidence available, the seriousness of the issue, and the need to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record. Such decisions will not be influenced by commercial considerations, institutional pressure, author reputation, or the potential impact of the action on the journal.

HALAL REVIEWS is committed to handling these matters consistently, fairly, and transparently, while respecting confidentiality, due process, and the legitimate interests of all parties involved.

The journal will review this policy periodically to ensure that its procedures remain consistent with recognised publication ethics standards and developments in scholarly publishing.