Reviewer Guidelines

HALAL REVIEWS operates a double-blind peer-review process to ensure the quality, originality, academic rigour, and ethical integrity of the manuscripts it publishes. Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the journal's scholarly standards and supporting authors in improving their work. All reviewers are expected to adhere to the following guidelines throughout the review process.

1. Confidentiality

All manuscripts submitted for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, distribute, discuss, or cite unpublished manuscripts or disclose their contents to any third party without prior permission from the Editor.

Under the double-blind peer-review process, the identities of reviewers are not disclosed to authors, and authors' identifying information is withheld from reviewers, as far as practicable. Reviewers must not attempt to identify the authors or contact them directly regarding the manuscript. Any communication concerning the review must be conducted through the Editorial Office.

2. Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may affect their impartiality. Such conflicts may include, but are not limited to:

  • Recent research collaboration or co-authorship with any of the manuscript's authors.

  • Current or recent supervisory, institutional, personal, or professional relationships with any author.

  • Financial, academic, or professional interests that could be affected by the manuscript's publication.

  • Direct involvement in the funding, conduct, or development of the research under review.

  • Competing interests relating to the manuscript's findings, methods, or conclusions.

Reviewers who identify a significant conflict of interest should decline the invitation or inform the Editor promptly so that an appropriate decision can be made regarding their participation.

3. Timeliness and Commitment

Reviewers are expected to respond to review invitations promptly and indicate whether they are able to undertake the review within the specified timeframe.

Upon accepting an invitation, reviewers should submit their evaluations within the deadline communicated by the Editorial Office. If additional time is required, reviewers must notify the Editorial Office as early as possible. Reviewers should not delay the editorial process by failing to communicate anticipated delays.

4. Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers should assess manuscripts objectively, critically, and constructively, taking into account the following criteria:

4.1 Originality and Relevance

  • Does the manuscript fall within the aims and scope of HALAL REVIEWS?

  • Does it address a relevant issue in halal studies, research, science, technology, industry, governance, or other areas covered by the journal?

  • Does it demonstrate originality and make a meaningful contribution to existing knowledge?

  • Does it engage appropriately with relevant literature and avoid unnecessary duplication of previously published work?

4.2 Academic Rigour and Methodological Soundness

  • Are the research objectives, questions, and arguments clearly articulated?

  • Is the methodology appropriate to the research objectives and adequately explained?

  • Are the data, evidence, sources, and analytical procedures sufficiently robust to support the conclusions?

  • Are the interpretations balanced, logically reasoned, and supported by appropriate evidence?

  • Where relevant, are the theoretical framework, conceptual approach, or Islamic legal and ethical perspectives applied appropriately?

4.3 Structure, Organisation, and Clarity

  • Is the manuscript logically organised and coherent?

  • Are the title, abstract, keywords, introduction, main discussion, and conclusion appropriate and consistent with the journal's requirements?

  • Are the research objectives, principal arguments, and findings or conclusions clearly presented?

  • Is the academic language clear, precise, and suitable for the intended readership?

4.4 References and Citation Practices

  • Are the cited sources relevant, reliable, and sufficiently comprehensive?

  • Are important and current scholarly publications considered where appropriate?

  • Are in-text citations and reference-list entries consistent with the journal's Author Guidelines?

  • Where applicable, are Arabic terms, transliterations, Islamic terminology, and references to primary Islamic sources presented accurately and consistently?

Reviewers should refer to the current Author Guidelines of HALAL REVIEWS for the required referencing style and transliteration conventions.

4.5 Research Ethics and Publication Integrity

  • Where applicable, has the research received the necessary ethical approval and complied with relevant ethical requirements?

  • Are potential concerns relating to plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, or redundant submission identified and reported?

  • Are funding sources, competing interests, and other relevant disclosures adequately addressed?

  • Are any concerns regarding the authenticity, reliability, or integrity of the research evidence brought to the attention of the Editor?

Any suspected research misconduct or serious ethical concern must be reported confidentially to the Editorial Office. Reviewers should not independently investigate or contact the authors to resolve such concerns.

5. Preparing and Submitting the Review

Reviewers should provide constructive, specific, impartial, and evidence-based feedback that assists the Editor in making an informed editorial decision and helps authors improve their manuscripts.

In preparing their reports, reviewers should:

  • Focus on the quality, content, methodology, and scholarly contribution of the manuscript rather than making personal remarks about the authors.

  • Clearly distinguish major concerns affecting the validity, originality, or suitability of the manuscript from minor issues involving wording, formatting, presentation, or clarification.

  • Identify specific passages, arguments, methodological limitations, or references wherever possible to support their comments.

  • Offer practical recommendations for improvement, where appropriate.

  • Ensure that their comments to the authors are consistent with their overall recommendation to the Editor.

Reviewers should avoid making unsupported allegations, imposing unnecessary citation requests, or recommending citations primarily to increase their own citation counts.

6. Reviewer Recommendations

At the conclusion of the review, reviewers should provide a clear recommendation to the Editor based on the quality of the manuscript, the review comments, and its suitability for HALAL REVIEWS.

The available recommendations are:

  • Accept: The manuscript meets the journal's requirements and requires no substantive revisions.

  • Minor Revisions: The manuscript is generally suitable for publication but requires limited corrections or clarifications.

  • Major Revisions: The manuscript requires substantial revision, further analysis, or significant improvements before it can be reconsidered.

  • Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements for publication because of significant limitations in its originality, scholarly quality, methodological soundness, ethical compliance, or relevance to the journal's scope.

The final editorial decision rests with the Editor or the authorised editorial representative. A reviewer's recommendation is advisory and does not, by itself, determine the final outcome.

7. Confidential Comments to the Editor

Reviewers may provide confidential comments to the Editor to communicate concerns that require separate editorial consideration, including suspected research misconduct, undisclosed conflicts of interest, serious methodological limitations, or concerns about the manuscript's suitability for the journal.

Such comments should be factual, professional, and supported by relevant evidence wherever possible. Confidential comments must not contradict the reviewer's substantive assessment without a clear explanation.

8. Use of Artificial Intelligence and Review Assistance

Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts throughout the peer-review process. Manuscripts and their contents must not be uploaded to publicly accessible artificial intelligence tools or other third-party services where confidentiality cannot be assured.

Reviewers should follow the journal's applicable policies on the use of artificial intelligence in peer review and must remain responsible for the accuracy, impartiality, and integrity of their evaluations. Any permitted use of AI-assisted tools must not compromise manuscript confidentiality or replace the reviewer's independent scholarly judgement.

9. Ethical Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers are expected to uphold the principles of fairness, impartiality, academic integrity, confidentiality, and professional conduct. They must not use unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal, academic, commercial, or professional advantage.

By accepting a review invitation, reviewers acknowledge their responsibility to evaluate the manuscript objectively, protect confidential information, disclose relevant conflicts of interest, and support a fair and transparent editorial process.

HALAL REVIEWS appreciates the time, expertise, and professional commitment of its reviewers in maintaining the journal's scholarly quality and integrity.